STKD.DIGITAL · BUSINESS IN MOTION
STKD.digital
Menu
All search and local visibility insights

Search and local visibility · 5 MIN READ

SEO vs. AIEO: What Should You Actually Pay For?

Before approving another search retainer, separate the work you already need from the experiments that deserve a small, measurable test.

THE SHORT ANSWER

Do not buy a second search program just because the proposal contains a new acronym. Buy a clearly defined set of improvements, a measurement plan, and someone accountable for deciding what happens next. AIEO, AEO and GEO are labels used for work intended to improve visibility in AI-generated answers. The labels alone tell you very little about the deliverable.

The short answer

The public debate is useful precisely because it is not settled. Helen Pollitt argues that AI search belongs inside existing organic and paid responsibilities. Another LinkedIn discussion asks whether existing SEO spend actually covers the new discovery surfaces. These are competing practitioner perspectives, not proof that either purchasing model fits your business. Helen Pollitt, AI For Search discussion.

Separate shared foundations from additional work

Google’s current AI-search guidance keeps the focus on useful, original content and core SEO. There is no special AI schema or required llms.txt file. Public crawling and indexing still matter, and the property’s Search generative AI control must allow inclusion. Inspect that setting rather than assuming code alone makes a site eligible. These are Google-specific controls, not a rule for every AI product. Google’s AI optimization guide, Search generative AI control.

A proposal should therefore distinguish foundational work from incremental experiments. Foundations include fixing inaccessible service pages, explaining your offer accurately, showing verifiable evidence, and making important content easy to navigate. Incremental work might include documenting a repeatable set of buyer questions across selected AI products, checking how your business is described, and investigating inaccurate or missing information.

Ask which changes would still be valuable if the AI experiment produced no measurable lift. Clear service boundaries, honest pricing explanations and stronger comparison pages can support sales directly. A collection of screenshots showing your brand once in a chatbot answer is a much weaker asset.

What actually changes the cost?

Scope drives cost more reliably than a fashionable service name. A single-location business with a coherent website presents a different assignment from a company with several service lines, conflicting location information and years of outdated content. Research, expert interviews, technical repairs and approval complexity all create real work.

Request a quote broken into discovery, implementation, content production, measurement and ongoing maintenance. Ask who supplies subject-matter expertise and who verifies factual claims. If the proposal assumes your team will provide interviews, original photography and approvals, include that internal time when comparing offers.

STKD does not publish a universal price here because a number without scope would be misleading. The useful buying question is: what will exist at the end of this phase that does not exist now? Require tangible answers such as corrected service pages, a technical issue register, a source-backed buyer guide and a measurement baseline.

A practical first-phase scope

Start with one valuable service and one defined audience rather than promising visibility everywhere. Choose questions a real prospect asks before buying: likely cost, reasons the service fails, alternatives, implementation requirements and who should not buy. Have an actual operator review each answer.

Build a baseline before changing the site. Record the buyer question, search or AI product, date, cited page and whether the answer was commercially accurate. Google’s Generative AI performance report adds impression evidence where enough data exists. Treat repeated observations as a sample, not a complete picture of every AI answer. Keep visibility separate from leads and sales. Google’s reporting documentation.

Our recommended acceptance test is straightforward: can a buyer understand the offer better, can your team explain what changed, and can you trace any resulting inquiries without pretending the measurement is complete?

The buying checklist

Use these questions to compare two proposals on the same basis. If a vendor refuses to separate guaranteed deliverables from hoped-for visibility, that is a reason to slow down.

Compare proposals against the same first-phase deliverables below. Ask the provider to identify what is already covered by your current SEO engagement and what is additional. Google also recommends asking about industry experience, expected results, measurement and the reasons for site changes. Google’s guidance on hiring an SEO.

  • Which tasks are genuinely additional to the SEO work we already fund?
  • Which buyer questions and service pages are in scope, and who reviews their accuracy?
  • What baseline and repeatable testing method will be delivered?
  • What is excluded: development, interviews, photography, approvals or reporting integration?
  • What would cause us to stop, revise or expand the experiment?
  • Who owns the content, accounts, tracking definitions and handover documentation?

When this is not the next investment

If your website misstates your offer, your inquiry form fails, or nobody follows up on qualified requests, fix those problems first. An additional discovery surface does not repair a broken buying journey. AI visibility work fits better when your offer is established and your team can act on demand. The objective is not to purchase a new acronym. It is to make accurate, useful information easier to find and turn relevant interest into a well-run conversation.

Sources and further reading

Find my biggest bottleneck